What Causes Ice Dams on a Roof?

Owner of Avalanche Home Services

Backed by 36 years in the trade and rare Fortified Certification, Avalanche owner Mike Conway shares expert roofing and exterior insight you can trust.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

If you’ve ever found a brown stain spreading across a ceiling in February, there’s a good chance an ice dam was behind it. Plenty of winter roof leaks in the Twin Cities start this way, with water backing up behind a ridge of ice at the eaves.

So what causes ice dams on a roof? The short answer is heat escaping from the house into the attic. The longer answer explains why some homes get them every winter and the house next door doesn’t.

How an Ice Dam Forms

An ice dam needs three things at once, according to the University of Minnesota Extension. There has to be snow on the roof, the upper part of the roof has to be above 32°F, and the lower edge has to stay below it.

When those conditions line up, snow on the warmer section melts and the water runs downhill. It reaches the overhang, which sits outside the heated part of the house and stays as cold as the outdoor air, and it freezes there. Each round of melting adds another layer, and the ridge of ice grows along the edge of the roof.

Once that ridge is in place, the meltwater coming down behind it has nowhere to go. It pools against the ice, works its way under the shingles, and can leak into the attic, insulation, walls, and ceilings. Shingles shed water running downhill. They aren’t built to hold back standing water, so an ice dam can cause a leak on a roof that’s otherwise in good shape.

What Causes Ice Dams on a Roof in Most Homes

Both the University of Minnesota Extension and the Minnesota Department of Commerce point to the same culprit, which is heat from the living space warming the roof deck. The Department of Commerce puts it plainly. It says ice dams aren’t caused by roofing, ventilation, or gutter problems, but by a house that leaks warm air.

That warm air gets into the attic in a few common ways.

  • Ceiling air leaks: The Extension says gaps around ceiling penetrations, such as light fixtures, are often the biggest contributor.
  • Thin or uneven insulation: Without enough insulation on the attic floor, heat from the rooms below passes straight through to the roof.
  • Other heat sources in the attic: Chimneys, exhaust vents, and ductwork that runs through the attic can all add warmth.

Heat loss also explains why two houses on the same street can look so different after a snowstorm. A home with an airtight, well-insulated ceiling keeps the roof deck close to the outdoor temperature, so snow sits evenly and melts slowly. A home that’s losing heat warms the upper roof, and the cycle of melting and refreezing starts.

Why Minnesota Winters Make It Worse

Ice dams need snow, and the Twin Cities get plenty of it. The Minnesota DNR lists the 1981 to 2010 normal annual snowfall for the Twin Cities at 54.4 inches. Heavy snow sits on the roof for weeks at a time, and long stretches of cold keep the eaves frozen while the attic below the upper roof stays warm. Ice dams and heavy snow are both on the list of winter damage we deal with on homes around White Bear Lake, and they often show up together after a big storm followed by a cold snap.

Common Mistakes That Make Ice Dams Worse

Some fixes homeowners try don’t touch what causes ice dams on a roof, and others create new damage. The Minnesota Department of Commerce advises against using chippers, chemicals, or heat to remove ice because they can damage shingles, gutters, and other roof parts. It also says adding roof vents, including powered vents, won’t stop ice dams and often makes them worse.

Climbing onto an icy roof or working from a ladder in winter is risky, too. The Extension cautions against it, and the Department of Commerce recommends hiring a professional for any roof or ladder work. Clearing snow with a roof rake from the ground can help in the short term, though the Extension notes it may damage roofing.

How to Stop Ice Dams Before They Start

The long-term fix is keeping heat out of the attic. The Extension recommends sealing air leaks between the house and the attic first, then adding insulation. The Department of Commerce suggests attic insulation to at least R-50 where space allows. Our attic insulation inspection looks at how much insulation is up there and where heat is getting through, and our attic insulation work addresses the gaps.

The roof itself plays a part in limiting damage. A reroofing guidance, for example, calls for an ice barrier that runs from the lowest edges of the roof to at least two feet inside the exterior wall line. That membrane doesn’t prevent ice dams, but it adds a waterproof layer under the shingles along the edge, where backed-up water is most likely to collect.

When we handle a residential roof replacement, we install IKO roofing systems as a RoofPro IKO Select contractor with IKO Codeplus and Fortified Wise affiliations, and our work is backed by a lifetime workmanship warranty.

What to Do If an Ice Dam Has Already Caused Damage

Once water has gotten inside, the priority is stopping more of it from coming in and then repairing the damage. The Extension advises waiting until ceilings and walls dry out before fixing interior finishes. On the roof side, a residential roof repair can address shingles or flashing that let water through. Avalanche Home Services also offers insurance assistance for homeowners filing a claim after ice dam damage.

We’re based in White Bear Lake, with more than 35 years of experience in the trade, and we hold an A- rating with the Better Business Bureau. If ice dams keep forming on your roof, or you’ve found a winter leak you can’t explain, call Avalanche Home Services to schedule an inspection before the next big snow.

RELATED ARTICLES

ABOUT MIKE CONWAY

OWNER · 36 YEARS EXPERIENCE

Mike Conway is the Owner of Avalanche Home Services and a lifelong tradesman driven by a simple belief: everyone deserves a safe home. For every 25 paying jobs, Mike donates a full installation to a family in need. With 36 years of hands-on experience and rare Fortified Certification, Mike brings honesty and expertise Twin Cities homeowners have come to trust.

Ready to Improve Your Home?

Trust our experienced team to deliver reliable roofing, siding, and exterior solutions that stand the test of time.